Fact, Fiction, and Factor Investing

The Journal of Portfolio Management (2023, 49 (2) 57-94)
Michele Aghassi, Cliff Asness, Charles Fattouche, and Tobias J. Moskowitz

Link to the paper

Abstract

Factor investing has been around for several decades, backed by an enormous body of literature, and yet it is still surrounded by much confusion and debate. Some of the rhetoric and myths have existed for a long time, while others have arisen in response to the difficult performance from 2018 to 2020 and the subsequent turnaround. This article examines many claims about factor investing; some are timeless, while others are focused on specific concerns that have emerged recently. The authors reference an extensive academic literature and perform simple, yet powerful, analysis to address these claims.

Scientific Portfolio AI- Generated Summary

This paper explores the size effect in finance, which refers to the tendency for small-cap stocks to outperform large-cap stocks over time. The authors, Ron Alquist, Ronen Israel, and Tobias Moskowitz, provide a comprehensive review of the literature on the size effect, including its history, empirical evidence, and theoretical explanations.

The authors begin by discussing the history of the size effect, which was first documented in the early 1980s by Rolf Banz. They then review the empirical evidence for the size effect, which has been mixed and sometimes conflicting. While some studies have confirmed the existence of the size effect, others have found it to be weak or nonexistent, particularly in international markets.

The authors then turn to the theoretical explanations for the size effect, which include risk-based, behavioral, and liquidity-based models. They argue that while each of these models has some empirical support, none of them fully explains the size effect on its own. Instead, the authors suggest that a combination of these factors, along with other market frictions and anomalies, may be responsible for the persistence of the size effect over time.

The paper also explores the practical implications of the size effect for investors, including the use of size-based investment strategies and the potential risks and challenges associated with these strategies. The authors note that while size-based strategies can be profitable, they also require careful attention to transaction costs, liquidity, and other factors that can affect returns.

Finally, the authors discuss some of the debates and challenges surrounding the size effect, including the potential for data mining and sample selection biases, as well as the role of recent market trends and changes in the global economy. They conclude that while the size effect remains a controversial and complex topic in finance, it is an important area of research that can help investors better understand the dynamics of the stock market and develop more effective investment strategies.